Recently I have started writing a preprocessor that wraps the C preprocessor for optimizing calls to sprintf, since it is the one of the bottlenecks of my application.
For GCC, it was easy for me to override the default C preprocessor, by using its
-wrapper options (how I have done it can be found in the
qrintf-gcc-wrapper files included in the above repository).
However I have so far been unable to find a similar command-line option for Clang. Is there any way to post-process the output of the preprocessor in Clang? Or do I need to modify the source code of Clang itself?
Thank you in advance.
PS. BTW it would be great if compile-time optimization of sprintf goes into Clang. Is there any chance of such possibility?
In the general case, it's not possible to optimize sprintf fully, because
its behavior depends on the current locale (this affects %d and %u, which
it looks like you optimize) and it might have libc-specific extensions, but
LLVM does optimize in some simple cases: for instance, a sprintf containing
no % is optimized into memcpy. I expect patches would be accepted to
implement further cases, such as handling %s and %c.
Thank you for the response. I am delighted to hear that.
I had thought that %d and %u weren't affected by the locale (since the
digits 0..9 and non-monetary use of positive/negative signs are IMO not
Sorry, yes, I think you’re right: they aren’t affected by locale by default, only if you use the ’ or I flags.
Thank you for confirmation.
FYI I have polished up the implementation (as a preprocessor wrapper) and
have taken a benchmark using a HTTP server that I develop. It gained 20%
performance boost by preprocessing calls to sprintf when using GCC, which
might be a proof that such an optimization does have real impact. The
details can be found here: