CMake pools for linking?

Hi,

I’ve noticed on both PCs and ARM boards that it is the linking process that “brings down” the system (makes it swap if it is not equipped with plenty of RAM). So I have been thinking if it would be possible to use the CMake pool feature to make the LLVM build system only issue one link command at a time - it seems a bit unfortunate that N simultaneous link commands are issued when you pretty much know beforehand that the system is only likely to be able to serve one link command, if that much, given its less-than-optimal-amount of memory.

I just want to hear if this is something that anybody is willing to look into - and if it is something that should be looked into at all? I don’t think I can figure this out on my own and I think it would be rather easy for somebody familiar with CMake.

I notice that there are a lot of low-end machines on the builders list in Zorg, so I cannot be the only one who would experience this addition as great.

Sincerely,
Mikael Lyngvig

Sigh. I only afterwards did a Google search and can see that the issue has been up before. The solution is to use flock:

export LD=flock /tmp/linker.lock ld.gold

(Which I have not tested yet as the build is commencing.)

P.S. Sorry for the noise, but not being omniscient is rather limiting at times :slight_smile:

– Mikael

Are you building in Debug mode? Buildbots should build in Release+Asserts mode.

Building LLVM in debug mode crashes even my quad-core i7 16GB RAM laptop, no wonder an odroid. But that’s LD’s fault. If you use Gold, everything works as expected.

Another alternative is using Ninja pools, but we’d need a CMake connection to generate the Ninja files with the link pools, which I don’t think it’s in production yet (there were some implementations on the development trunk).

cheers,
–renato