cross-project-tests doesn't appear to send commit-mail

Is cross-project-tests sending commit mail to some mailing list? It doesn’t seem to have sent it to any mailing list I’m on. So it’s hard to send post-commit feedback/keep track of changes/do post-commit review.

(for now I’ve sent post-commit feedback via github: https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/commit/fff2c0f0bf0b3ed9948562eb6b2987f7d64807f4 )

Is cross-project-tests sending commit mail to some mailing list? It doesn't seem to have sent it to any mailing list I'm on. So it's hard to send post-commit feedback/keep track of changes/do post-commit review.

They should be on the all-commits list, but I don't think many people subscribe
to that. Do you have a suggestion for which list these commit mails should
go to ?

-Tom

Is cross-project-tests sending commit mail to some mailing list? It doesn’t seem to have sent it to any mailing list I’m on. So it’s hard to send post-commit feedback/keep track of changes/do post-commit review.

They should be on the all-commits list, but I don’t think many people subscribe
to that. Do you have a suggestion for which list these commit mails should
go to ?

Ah, hmm… maybe I should subscribe to that & do some aggressive filtering?

I think cross-project-tools is probably sufficiently llvm-ish and low-traffic that it could probably get lumped into llvm-commits if other folks are OK with that.

  • Dave

I've replied to the comment on the commit; do those comments also go only
to the all-commits list?

Is there possibly an other-commits list, for subprojects that don't have
their own list? It seems like, wanting to see cross-projects-tests
commits shouldn't require subscribing to the all-commits fire hose.
--paulr

From: Tom Stellard <tstellar@redhat.com>
Sent: Thursday, October 28, 2021 8:42 PM
To: David Blaikie <dblaikie@gmail.com>; Tozer, Stephen
<stephen.tozer@sony.com>; Henderson, James <James.Henderson@sony.com>;
Robinson, Paul <paul.robinson@sony.com>; Adrian Prantl
<aprantl@apple.com>; Jonas Devlieghere <jdevlieghere@apple.com>; llvm-dev
<llvm-dev@lists.llvm.org>
Subject: Re: [llvm-dev] cross-project-tests doesn’t appear to send commit-
mail

Is cross-project-tests sending commit mail to some mailing list? It
doesn’t seem to have sent it to any mailing list I’m on. So it’s hard to
send post-commit feedback/keep track of changes/do post-commit review.

They should be on the all-commits list, but I don’t think many people
subscribe
to that. Do you have a suggestion for which list these commit mails
should
go to ?

-Tom

I’ve replied to the comment on the commit; do those comments also go only
to the all-commits list?

Replies to the github comment (& the comment itself) don’t go to any list that I know of - only the author/people who have replied, I think. So I saw your reply, but I doubt it went to anyone else. (maybe folks who have explicitly subscribed to comments thorugh github in some way)

Hi Tom,

I don’t know what the old debuginfo-tests project would have gone to, but probably llvm-commits, and that seems like the most plausible list for cross-project-tests as well.

–paulr

Hi Tom,

I don’t know what the old debuginfo-tests project would have gone to, but probably llvm-commits, and that seems like the most plausible list for cross-project-tests as well.

Ok, I created an IWG ticket for this and I'll try to get it set up.
https://github.com/llvm/llvm-iwg/issues/79

-Tom