llc is taking a long time at -O1 to convert *.bc to *.s

Hi All,

I am using llvm-3.0 release version for compiling some files. I have a cpp file on which I did a few custom passes. After that I used llc to convert the *.bc file to *.s file at –O1 optimization level. llc took ~2630 seconds to perform this conversion. I timed llc and these are the top three passes that is taking most of the time.

—User Time— --System Time-- --User+System-- —Wall Time— — Name —

1816.1735 ( 77.8%) 23.3215 ( 69.7%) 1839.4950 ( 77.6%) 1839.4132 ( 77.6%) Simple Register Coalescing

493.5948 ( 21.1%) 9.1846 ( 27.4%) 502.7794 ( 21.2%) 502.7681 ( 21.2%) X86 DAG->DAG Instruction Selection

5.7244 ( 0.2%) 0.0000 ( 0.0%) 5.7244 ( 0.2%) 5.7204 ( 0.2%) Machine Instruction LICM

I am running this in a fairly new Xeon server. Furthermore, at –O0, llc takes less than 20 seconds to complete. Is this behavior expected and is there a way to disable Simple Register Coalescing pass without switching to –O0 optimization level to get around this problem?

Thanks

Sreekumar

Sreekumar,
Without a test case, we really can't determine if this is expected behavior. Certainly, we'd prefer -O1 compile-times to be relatively fast. Have you tried this with a ToT clang? If you're still seeing such poor performance then I suggest filing a bug (http://llvm.org/bugs). Please include a test case and the command line arguments to reproduce the problem. I believe ToT is compatible with 3.0 bitcode files, so you could just submit your bitcode file.

Chad

Without coalescing you will get really bad code, but the llc option to turn it off is -join-intervals=0.

There is a good chance the performance problem has already been fixed on trunk.

/jakob