Updating release docs and minimal tools

Project Infrastructure LLVM Dev List Archives
1

Folks,

I'm in the process of updating this page:

http://llvm.org/docs/HowToReleaseLLVM.html

which had its last review in the middle ages.

In particular, I'm removing "dragonegg" from the list of requirements,
changing the "build" instructions to use the test-release script (by
pointing it to the right doc [1]), and updating the list of
requirements.

CMake is now required to be 3.4.3 for *all* platforms, and Ninja is
best if 1.5+ (but not required). That's the easy part. But I'm not
sure about the compiler version...

Some of the versions cite gcc 3.4.5 in mingw, which I find hard to
believe, given the recent c++11 additions. It also doesn't mention
MSVC or Clang at all, which is a serious lack of information.

Since I haven't been paying that much attention to the progress (and
my minimum version is GCC 4.8), I'd like for people to chime in on
which versions work where. The versions used to matter across arches
because of basic support, but now, all of that is gone in GCC, and we
only have MSVC to worry about.

Last I remember, Linux (all arches) minimum was 4.7.2, though there
may be some newer developments requiring 4.8.2.

I believe Clang 3.6 was once the minimum on all arches and OSs, but
this may also have changed.

MSVC was once 2012 but may recently have changed to allow more C++11
goodness, and I have no idea about Mingw.

Also, is there *any* pre-GPLv3 GCC in Mac or BSD that can compile
Clang at this day and age?

Please, let me know and I'll update the doc to the appropriate values.

cheers,
--renato

[1] http://llvm.org/docs/ReleaseProcess.html

2

Folks,

I'm in the process of updating this page:

How To Release LLVM To The Public — LLVM 18.0.0git documentation

which had its last review in the middle ages.

In particular, I'm removing "dragonegg" from the list of requirements,
changing the "build" instructions to use the test-release script (by
pointing it to the right doc [1]), and updating the list of
requirements.

CMake is now required to be 3.4.3 for *all* platforms, and Ninja is
best if 1.5+ (but not required). That's the easy part. But I'm not
sure about the compiler version...

Some of the versions cite gcc 3.4.5 in mingw, which I find hard to
believe, given the recent c++11 additions. It also doesn't mention
MSVC or Clang at all, which is a serious lack of information.

Since I haven't been paying that much attention to the progress (and
my minimum version is GCC 4.8), I'd like for people to chime in on
which versions work where. The versions used to matter across arches
because of basic support, but now, all of that is gone in GCC, and we
only have MSVC to worry about.

Last I remember, Linux (all arches) minimum was 4.7.2, though there
may be some newer developments requiring 4.8.2.

I believe Clang 3.6 was once the minimum on all arches and OSs, but
this may also have changed.

MSVC was once 2012 but may recently have changed to allow more C++11
goodness, and I have no idea about Mingw.

MSVC 2013 and 2015 are the only MSVC's that are supported currently.

-- Sean Silva

3

And I guess http://llvm.org/docs/GettingStarted.html#host-c-toolchain-both-compiler-and-standard-library should be the source of truth about what we support?

4

And I guess http://llvm.org/docs/GettingStarted.html#host-c-toolchain-both-compiler-and-standard-library should be the source of truth about what we support?

5

Ah, yes. Most of those "known" problems can go away, because they're
on unsupported compilers. Some of the comments there I added 5 years
ago, too. I think all those docs need a serious re-work.

Thanks!
--renato