Are 'make check' failures of interest in llvm-gcc?

Project Infrastructure LLVM Dev List Archives
1

Hi,

I have run 'make check' in llvm-gcc 4.0 (svn version).
I got some failures, mostly gcc.apple tests fail (and a gcc.c-torture
test, namely 20000804-1.c)

Are these tests of any interest to llvm-gcc itself, or they are problems
with "upstream" ? (gcc 4.0).
If the former, should I submit bugreports about them?

Thanks,
--Edwin

2

Could be either. I'm running this suite and seeing a lot more failures than
you're reporting; many builtin optimizations are not done, many expected
warnings do not match gcc syntax, etc. There are also some real bugs,
but all the ones I know of are related to rarely used features, mostly gcc
extensions.

It would be more useful to do this in 4.2 IMO.

3

Dale Johannesen wrote:

  
Could be either. I'm running this suite and seeing a lot more
failures than
you're reporting;

I didn't wait for all the tests to finish, just seen that there are many...

many builtin optimizations are not done, many expected
warnings do not match gcc syntax, etc. There are also some real bugs,
but all the ones I know of are related to rarely used features,
mostly gcc
extensions.

It would be more useful to do this in 4.2 IMO.
  

Ok.

--Edwin