MIssing llvm-commits messages

Project Infrastructure LLVM Dev List Archives
1

Has anyone noticed missing llvm-commits messages? Not all commits seem to generate emails to llvm-commits.

For example, I can’t find an email for this commit: https://github.com/llvm/llvm-project/commit/4a6e13ad88ddcc0ab92ace49d4c761921e7f7070

Nor does it appear here: http://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/llvm-commits/Week-of-Mon-20191209/date.html

2

Yep, there seems to be an issue with commits containing non-ASCII
symbols (in Author: line?)

Has anyone noticed missing llvm-commits messages? Not all commits seem to generate emails to llvm-commits.

For example, I can’t find an email for this commit: [CommandLine] Add missing Callbacks · llvm/llvm-project@4a6e13a · GitHub

Nor does it appear here: The llvm-commits The Week Of Monday 9 December 2019 Archive by date

Roman

3

Yep, there seems to be an issue with commits containing non-ASCII
symbols (in Author: line?)

Ah, perhaps, but I don’t seen anything obvious, at least not in the log. And the author has other commits just before and after that did generate a messages, so it seems somewhat random to me.

4

I noticed a similar thing back in August: http://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/llvm-dev/2019-August/134516.html

Russ

5

(CC llvm-commits-owner and llvm-admin)

Here’s another previous thread on the subject of unicode characters in commit logs: http://lists.llvm.org/pipermail/llvm-dev/2019-November/137290.html

But as Don points out, this particular case appears to be something different, unless there’s something hiding in that commit which I’m not spotting.

-Greg

6

Has anyone noticed missing llvm-commits messages? Not all commits seem to generate emails to llvm-commits.

For example, I can’t find an email for this commit: [CommandLine] Add missing Callbacks · llvm/llvm-project@4a6e13a · GitHub

It looks like this commit was part of a push that contained 2 commits.
Our mailer script was supposed to be able to handle this case, but
it's possible there is a bug.

When we were setting up the email, we did notice 1 missed email
due to the webhook not being initiated from the GitHub side, but
this is not the case here.

-Tom

7

> Has anyone noticed missing llvm-commits messages? Not all commits seem to generate emails to llvm-commits.
>
> For example, I can’t find an email for this commit: [CommandLine] Add missing Callbacks · llvm/llvm-project@4a6e13a · GitHub
>

It looks like this commit was part of a push that contained 2 commits.
Our mailer script was supposed to be able to handle this case, but
it's possible there is a bug.

When we were setting up the email, we did notice 1 missed email
due to the webhook not being initiated from the GitHub side, but
this is not the case here.

Here is another commit that looks like it never made it to the list:

It also has unicode characters in the commit log.

~Aaron